
I have only seen a preview of the show. They tell us that the story is the same, but updated.
My main gripe so far is making Starbuck a woman. An angry woman. Sorry, this doesn't work for me. We need the buddy feeling of the two leads. He is supposed to be the relaxed cigar-smoking, gambler who stays cool. He's a joker and a ladies' man. Apollo is the one who gets emotional. Hopefully, the new Starbuck won't be too angry. Boomer is a woman too. Okay, I can deal with this because this is a support character and could be either. I cannot find Athena or Sheba in the new cast list. Did they decide they were now superfluous?
Katee Sackhoff, the new Starbuck, tells us to "Deal with it."
They appear to have made the Cylons human-shaped. Production costs are down, but will it work? Cylons don't stop. They keep coming. They don't have expressions, so you don't know what they are thinking. You would know if a 6ft+ Cylon had come into the room. They were scary.
If they look like humans, this is a different show. Number 6 is a female human-shaped Cylon. Well this has just become Bladerunner in space. Yay.
The uniforms are no longer brown suede. They look like the uniforms out of Enterprise. Not a bad thing in itself, but why change such cool looking outfits?
On the postitive side, the special effects look good. They have very good looking Vipers, and the Battlestars don't look bad either. I hope the writers remember that it's characters that drive the story, not special effects.
Apparently, the series has been commisioned so people must have liked it. Maybe I just don't like people messing with a good thing. Like Lucas adding a crap Jabba to a New Hope, but we won't get into that now.
This is airing here next week, so we'll see.